When should I use __slots__ in a Python class, and what are the tradeoffs? #168147
-
BodyI recently came across a Python class that uses But how much of a difference does it actually make in practice? Are there any downsides to using Guidelines
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
Replies: 4 comments
-
|
Good question, slots can definitely help in some situations, but it’s not always worth using. By default, Python gives every object a dynamic dict, which allows you to add attributes at runtime, but that also uses more memory. When you define slots, you tell Python exactly which attributes an object can have, and it skips creating the dict, which can lead to significant memory savings, especially if you’re creating thousands or millions of instances. That said, there are tradeoffs. You lose the ability to add new attributes unless you explicitly include dict in the slots, and using slots can make inheritance a bit trickier, especially when combining it with other classes that also define slots. Also worth noting: if you’re using dataclasses, you’ll need to explicitly enable slots via @DataClass(slots=True) (available in Python 3.10+). In general, slots makes sense in performance-critical systems, like compilers, interpreters, or memory-heavy data processing pipelines, but for most everyday Python code, the benefits are usually too small to matter. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
To add another perspective, I will disagree with the other answers and says that they should always be used as the default, unless dynamic attribute setting is a desired behavior (which is, in fact, very rarely the case). Not only do they improve memory consumption and performance by avoiding the dict, but they also make your code safer! from dataclasses import dataclass
from typing import Self
@dataclass
class Foo:
name: str
def set_name(self, new_name: str) -> Self:
self.nam = new_name
return selfThis look more like a typo than intended behavior, right? However if I specify And when running the code it crashes rather than silently NOT updating my instance name: Traceback (most recent call last):
File "C:\Users\tibo\python_codes\pyochain\t.py", line 14, in <module>
Foo("test").set_name("new_name")
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^^^^^^^^^^^^
File "C:\Users\tibo\python_codes\pyochain\t.py", line 10, in set_name
self.nam = new_name
^^^^^^^^
AttributeError: 'Foo' object has no attribute 'nam' and no __dict__ for setting new attributes. Did you mean: 'name'?The only downsides they can bring, as already pointed out, is that they can make inerhitance trickier. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
slots is a Python class feature that tells the interpreter to store instance attributes in a fixed, static structure instead of each instance having its own dict. In practice, this can significantly reduce memory usage when you create many instances of a class (for example, thousands or millions), and it can provide a small speed improvement for attribute access due to the more compact layout. However, for most everyday applications, the performance difference is negligible, and the memory savings only matter at scale. There are also downsides: classes using slots cannot have arbitrary new attributes added at runtime, they interact less smoothly with multiple inheritance, and features like pickling, weak references, and some debugging or introspection tools may require extra work. Because of these trade-offs, slots is not commonly used in typical application code and is mostly seen in performance-sensitive libraries, data-heavy systems, or low-level frameworks where memory efficiency is critical. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
slots is mainly a memory optimization feature in Python. By default, instances store attributes in a per-object dictionary (dict), which provides flexibility but adds memory overhead for every instance. @DataClass(slots=True) (Python 3.10+), which provides the benefits of slots while keeping code readable and maintainable. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
Good question, slots can definitely help in some situations, but it’s not always worth using. By default, Python gives every object a dynamic dict, which allows you to add attributes at runtime, but that also uses more memory. When you define slots, you tell Python exactly which attributes an object can have, and it skips creating the dict, which can lead to significant memory savings, especially if you’re creating thousands or millions of instances. That said, there are tradeoffs. You lose the ability to add new attributes unless you explicitly include dict in the slots, and using slots can make inheritance a bit trickier, especially when combining it with other classes that also define …